Robert Christgau: Dean of American Rock Critics

Consumer Guide:
  User's Guide
  Grades 1990-
  Grades 1969-89
  And It Don't Stop
Books:
  Book Reports
  Is It Still Good to Ya?
  Going Into the City
  Consumer Guide: 90s
  Grown Up All Wrong
  Consumer Guide: 80s
  Consumer Guide: 70s
  Any Old Way You Choose It
  Don't Stop 'til You Get Enough
Xgau Sez
Writings:
  And It Don't Stop
  CG Columns
  Rock&Roll& [new]
  Rock&Roll& [old]
  Music Essays
  Music Reviews
  Book Reviews
  NAJP Blog
  Playboy
  Blender
  Rolling Stone
  Billboard
  Video Reviews
  Pazz & Jop
  Recyclables
  Newsprint
  Lists
  Miscellany
Bibliography
NPR
Web Site:
  Home
  Site Map
  Contact
  What's New?
    RSS
Social Media:
  Substack
  Bluesky
  [Twitter]
Carola Dibbell:
  Carola's Website
  Archive
CG Search:
Google Search:

And It Don't Stop on Substack

Robert Christgau's newsletter And It Don't Stop appears three (or four) times a month on Substack. Subscribe here.

Robert Christgau's Big-Hearted Theory of Pop

Book Reports features reviews of not only the pop-music tomes you'd predict but also literary fiction, Marxist-adjacent cultural commentary, feminist debates over pornography, and even books about the past decade's financial crisis. It follows a collection that Christgau published last year, Is It Still Good to Ya? Fifty Years of Rock Criticism, 1967-2017, which includes Christgau's takes on, among many other things, classic rock, Kanye West, the music of Desert Storm, Lollapalooza, Ladysmith Black Mambazo, and so-called guilty pleasures--a category that Christgau rejects, since, for rock critics, as he puts it, "pleasure is where meaning begins." Together, these collections make the sneaky case that Christgau is not just the Dean of American Rock Critics, his self-awarded and perhaps slightly off-putting nickname, but one of America's sharper public intellectuals of the past half century, and certainly one of its most influential--not to mention one of the better stylists in that cohort. Fun is a big part of why.

--David Cantwell, The New Yorker

News

Consumer Guide (June 2010)

New Consumer Guide for June 2010. Featured albums:

  • African Pearls: Congo: Pont Sur le Congo (Syllart) [A]
  • Elizabeth Cook: Welder (31 Tigers) [A]
  • Hole: Nobody's Daughter (Mercury) [A-]
  • Nas & Damian "JR. Gong" Marley: Distant Relatives (Def Jam) [A-]
  • Ouaga Affair: Hard Won Sound of the Upper Volta 1974-78 (Savannahphone) [B+]
  • Tin Huey: Before Obscurity: The Bushflow Tapes (Smog Veil) [B+]
  • Titus Andronicus: The Monitor (XL) [A-]
  • Julian Marley: Awake (Universal Republic) [B]

Honorable Mentions: The Hold Steady, Jimi Tenor/Tony Allen, Kate Nash, Fishtank Ensemble, Issa Juma and Super Wanyika Stars, The Apples in Stereo, Egypt Noir: Nubian Soul Treasures, Ryan Leslie; The Fall, Robin Thicke, Lagos Disco Inferno, Tony Allen, This Moment in Black History, African Pearls: Côte d'Ivoire: West African Crossroads, Timbila, Sierre Leone's Refugee All Stars, Mean Jeans; Eric Bibb, Hendy Odem, Ton3x, Gimmie Gimmie Gimmie, Ryan Leslie, Strange Boys, Etran Finatawa.

Choice Cuts: Fefe Dobson, Court Yard Hounds, Mayer Hawthorne, NOFX.

More Duds: Cobie Caillat, The Dillinger Escape Plan, The Gallows, Lady Antebellum, Shelby Lynne, Ky-Mani Marley, Pissed Jeans, Trey Songz, Carrie Underwood.

Rock & Roll &: Pops as Pop

New Rock & Roll & column at Barnes & Noble Review:

Consumer Guide (May 2010)

New Consumer Guide for May 2010. Featured albums:

  • Balkan Beat Box: Blue Eyed Black Boy (Nat Geo Music) [A-]
  • Beatles Beginnings (Rhythmand Blues) [A-]
  • Johnny Cash: American VI: Ain't No Grave (American) [A]
  • Cornershop: Judy Sucks a Lemon for Breakfast (Ample Play) [A-]
  • Dan le Sac vs Scroobius Pip: The Logic of Chance (Sunday Best) [A-]
  • Merle Haggard: I Am What I Am (Vanguard) [B+]
  • MC Esoteric: Saving Seamus Ryan (Fly Casual) [A-]
  • Quasi: American Gong (Kill Rock Stars) [A-]
  • Surfer Blood: Astro Coast (Kanine) [A-]
  • MGMT: Congratulations (Columbia) [C+]

Honorable Mentions: Gogol Bordello, Hot Chip, Drive-By Truckers, Texas Tornados, Jaguar Love, Carolina Chocolate Drops, The Holmes Brothers, Danny Barnes; Bela Fleck, Broken Bells, Lyle Lovett, Drakkar Sauna, James Hand, Willie Nelson; Peter Karp & Sue Foley, Easton Corbin, St. Vincent, The Reverend Horton Heat, 7L & Esoteric, Beach House.

Choice Cuts: Gorillaz, Flight of the Conchords, Bright Eyes/Neva Dinova, She & Him.

More Duds: Bobby Bare Jr., Built to Spill, Jakob Dylan, The Low Anthem, Meth Ghost and Rae, Miike Snow, Rain Machie, 7L & Esoteric, Blake Shelton.

Consumer Guide (April 2010)

New Consumer Guide for April 2010. Featured albums:

  • Mose Allison: The Way of the World (Anti-) [B+]
  • MC Paul Barman: Thought Balloon Mushroom Cloud (Househusband) [A-]
  • The Bundles: The Bundles (K) [A-]
  • Fever Ray: Fever Ray (Rabid/Mute) [A-]
  • Ricardo Lemvo and Makina Loca: Isabela (Mopiato Music) [A-]
  • Ricardo Lemvo and Makina Loca: Retrospectiva (Mopiato Music) [A-]
  • Lil Wayne: No Ceilings (free download) [A-]
  • Love Is All: Two Thousand and Ten Injuries (Polyvinyl) [A-]
  • Kinito Méndez: Éxitos de Kinito Méndez (J & N) [A-]
  • Freeway & Jake One: Stimulus Package (Rhymesayers Entertainment) [B]

Honorable Mentions: The Da Vincis, Project Ahimsa Presents Global Lingo, Los Campesinos!, Bettie Serveert, MC Paul Barman; Wetdog, Röyksopp, Donwill, Kid Cudi, Dr. Dooom, Roberto Rodriguez, Lil Wayne, Kleenex LiLiPUT; Gucci Mane, Felt, Gil Scott-Heron, Souls of Mischief, Abraham Inc., Snoop Dogg Presents the West Coast Blueprint, Cock Lorge Band, Ludacris.

Choice Cuts: Peter Gabriel, Masha Qrella, Young Money, Lil Wayne.

More Duds: Dap C & Lil Wayne, Dead Man's Bones, Dum Dum Girls, Fabolous, Freddie Gibbs, Hopsin, The Knife, Kool Keith, Snoop Dogg.

Rock & Roll &: The Triumph of the Id

New Rock & Roll & column at Barnes & Noble Review:

Consumer Guide (March 2010)

New Consumer Guide for March 2010. Featured albums:

  • David Bazan: Curse Your Branches (Barsuk) [A-]
  • Dessa: A Badly Broken Code (Doomtree) [A-]
  • Everybody Was in the French Resistance . . . Now!: Fixing the Charts Vol. 1 (Cooking Vinyl) [A-]
  • The Flaming Lips: Embryonic (Warner Bros.) [A-]
  • Gabriel Johnson: Fra_ctured (Electrofone) [A-]
  • Lady Gaga: The Fame Monster (Interscope) [A-]
  • Boban i Marko Markovic: Devla: Blown Away to Dancefloor Heaven (Piranha) [A-]
  • Youssou N'Dour: I Bring What I Love (Nonesuch) [A-]
  • Spoon: Transference (Merge) [A-]
  • Vampire Weekend: Contra (XL) [A]
  • The Whitefield Brothers: Earthology (Now-Again) [A-]
  • Alicia Keys: The Element of Freedom (J) [B]

Honorable Mentions: Jon Hassell, The Magnetic Fields, Whiskey in the Jar, Mary J. Blige, V.V. Brown, Fuck Buttons, Annie, BalkanBeats, Clem Snide, Hot Club de Norvege, Jon Hassell, DJ/Rupture & Matt Shadetek, Queen Ifrica, Sade, Nneka, Blk Jks, Four Tet, Fool's Gold

Choice Cuts: Burkina Electric, Sister Fa, Ke$ha, Discovery, Florence + the Machine

More Duds: Blk Jks, The Horrors, Leona Lewis, Matisyahu, Neon Indian

Rock & Roll &: Smart and Smarter

New Rock & Roll & column at Barnes & Noble Review:

Consumer Guide (February 2010)

New Consumer Guide for February 2010. Featured albums:

  • The Dirty Projectors: Bitte Orca (Domino) [B+]
  • Fruit Bats: The Ruminant Band (Sub Pop) [A-]
  • Group Bombino: Guitars From Agadez Vol. 2 (Sublime Frequencies) [A-]
  • Paul Kelly: Greatest Hits: Songs From the South; Volumes 1 & 2 (Capitol) [B+]
  • Jeffrey Lewis & the Junkyard: Em Are I (Rough Trade) [A-]
  • The Mountain Goats: The Life of the World to Come (4AD) [A-]
  • Rail Band: Rail Band 2: Mansa (Belle Epoque) [A-]
  • Rail Band: Rail Band 3: Dioba (Belle Epoque) [B+]
  • Peter Stampfel: Dook of the Beatniks (Piety Street Files & Archaic) [A-]
  • The Decemberists: The Hazards of Love (Capitol) [C]

Honorable Mentions: Vieux Farka Touré, The Very Best, Jill Sobule, Group Doueh, Tinariwen, Willowz, Dr. Boogie Presents Heavy Jelly, Freedy Johnston, Tea Cozies, The Very Best [mixtape], The Red Krayola With Art & Language, Ghana Special, Chuck Prophet, Rosanne Cash, La Drivers Union Por Por Group, Thao With the Get Down Stay Down, Bibio

Choice Cuts: Menya, Bruce Robison, Julian Casablancas, Norah Jones, Kris Kristofferson

More Duds: Andrew Bird, The Boxer Rebellion, Dan Deacon, Deradoorian, Jolie Holland, Noah and the Whale, A Sunny Day in Glasgow

Rock & Roll &: Resuscitations and Business Plans

New Rock&Roll& column at Barnes & Noble Review, wrapping up 2009.

Consumer Guide (January 2010)

New Consumer Guide for January 2010. Featured albums:

  • The Chemical Brothers: Brotherhood (Limited Edition) (Virgin) [A-]
  • Death Cab for Cutie: The Open Door (Atlantic, EP) [A-]
  • Ghostface Killah: Fish N Chips (Mick Boogie Entertainment) [B+]
  • Ghostface Killah: Ghostdini Wizard of Poetry in Emerald City (Def Jam) [A-]
  • God Help the Girl: God Help the Girl (Matador) [A-]
  • Richard Hell: Destiny Street Repaired (Insound.com) [A-]
  • A Place to Bury Strangers: Exploding Head (Mute) [A-]
  • Shakira: She Wolf (Epic) [A-]
  • Q-Tip: Kamaal the Abstract (Battery) [B-]

Honorable Mentions: Amerie, Mi Loco Tango, God Help the Girl, Ralph Carney's Serious Jass Project, Soulico; Regenerated Headpiece, Wyclef Jean, Khingz, Massive Attack, Themselves, M.O.P., John Mayer, Rihanna, Jamie T, Themselves, Clipse, A Place to Bury Strangers; Brother Ali, Rakim, Q-Tip, KRS-One & Buckshot, Grand Puba, Big Star, Third Eye Blind

Choice Cuts: John Fogerty, Wale, Ian Hunter, Ghostface Killah

More Duds: Mariah Carey, Chester French, 50 Cent, M.O.P., Me'Shell Ndegeocello, Subtle, Swollen Members, Rob Thomas

Rolling Stone Decade Ballot

Robert Christgau's ballot for Rolling Stone's The Decade's Best Songs & Albums.

Rock & Roll &: Not So Misterioso

New Rock&Roll& column at Barnes & Noble Review, on Thelonious Monk, Not So Misterioso.

Consumer Guide (December 2009)

New Consumer Guide for December 2009. Featured albums:

  • Mulatu Astatke: New York-Addis-London: The Story of Ethio Jazz 1965-1975 (Strut) [A-]
  • Eva & the Heartmaker: Let's Keep This Up Forever (Sony) [B+]
  • Girls: Album (True Panther/Fantasy Trashcan) [A-]
  • Veda Hille: This Riot Life (Ape House) [A-]
  • Nirvana: Live at Reading (DGC) [A]
  • Jay Reatard: Watch Me Fall (Matador) [A-]
  • The Rough Guide to Gypsy Revival (World Music Network) [B+]
  • Tegan and Sara: Sainthood (Vapor/Sire) [A-]
  • tUnE-yArDs: BiRd-BrAiNs (4AD) [A]
  • The xx: The xx (XL/Young Turks) [A]
  • Lynyrd Skynyrd: God & Guns (RoadRunner/Loud & Proud) [C+]

Honorable Mentions: Kottarashky, Gogol Bordello, Joe Nichols, NOFX, The Asteroids Galaxy Tour, BalkanBeats: A Night in Berlin, The Raveonettes, The Black Crowes, Scream Along With Billy, Talk Normal, Sam Baker, Tom Waits, Bob Dylan, The Ettes, A Hawk and a Hacksaw, Vivian Girls, Tommy T

Choice Cuts: Tim McGraw, Asylum Street Spankers, Musafir, Toby Keith, Kitka, Taylor Swift

More Duds: Ingrid Michaelson, Noisettes, Karen O and the Kids, Susana and the Magical Orchestra, Wavves, Wye Oak

Rock & Roll &: Paisley's Progress

New Rock&Roll& column at Barnes & Noble Review, on Brad Paisley, American Saturday Night.

Consumer Guide (November 2009)

New Consumer Guide for November 2009. Featured albums:

  • The Avett Brothers: I and Love and You (American) [A-]
  • Franco: Francophonic Vol. 2 (Sterns Africa) [A+]
  • Nellie McKay: Normal as Blueberry Pie: A Tribute to Doris Day (Verve) [A]
  • Modest Mouse: No One's First, and You're Next (Epic) [A-]
  • Jemina Pearl: Break It Up (Universal Motown) [B+]
  • Various artists: The Rough Guide to Tango Revival (World Music Network) [A-]
  • Loudon Wainwright III: High Wide & Handsome: The Charlie Poole Project (161) [A]
  • White Denim: Fits (Downtown) [A-]
  • Arctic Monkeys: Humbug (Domino) [B]

Honorable Mentions: Kid Sister, No Age, Telekinesis, Amira Sagati, Yoko Ono Plastic Ono Band, Maria Muldaur & Her Garden of Joy, Bygones, Basement Jaxx, Richmond Fontaine, Think Global: Tango, The Backsliders, The Donnas, Cymbals Eat Guitars, Lightning Bolt, Blitzen Trapper, La Roux, The Rough Guide to Tango, The Pica Beats, Mission of Burma, Loudon Wainwright III, Monsters of Folk, The Avett Brothers, Future of the Left, Paramore, Phoenix

Choice Cuts: White Denim, The Slits, Anjulie, Lightning Bolt

More Duds: The Avett Brothers, Franz Ferdinand, Tango Around the World, Telepathe, Martha Wainwright, Wild Beasts

Rock & Roll &: A Classic Illustrated

New Rock&Roll& column at Barnes & Noble Review, reviewing R. Crumb, The Book of Genesis Illustrated.

NPR: Nellie McKay's Love Letter to Doris Day

NPR music review: Nellie McKay's Love Letter to Doris Day.

Consumer Guide (October 2009)

New Consumer Guide for October 2009. Featured albums:

  • The Black Eyed Peas: The E.N.D. (Interscope) [A]
  • Goran Bregovic: Alkohol (Wrasse) [A-]
  • Jay-Z: The Blueprint 3 (Roc Nation) [A-]
  • Miranda Lambert: Revolution (Columbia) [A-]
  • Various artists: Now That's What I Call Party Hits! (Capitol) [A-]
  • Various artists: The Rough Guide to Merengue Dance (World Music Network) [A-]
  • Seprewa Kasa: Seprewa Kasa (Riverboat) [B+]
  • Serengeti: Conversations With Kenny & The Legacy of Lee (Goldenfloyd) [B+]
  • They Might Be Giants: Here Come the 123s (Disney Sound) [A-]
  • Ginuwine: A Man's Thoughts (Asylum) [C]

Honorable Mentions: Raekwon, Geoff Muldaur and the Texas Sheiks, Major Lazer, They Might Be Giants, Son de Madera, Wonderlick; Amsterdam Klezmer Band, Grant Peeples, Sila & the Afrofunk Experience, Speech Debelle, Living Colour, Yo La Tengo, Chris Smither; Grant Langston, Chrisette Michele, The Rough Guide to the Afrobeat Revolution, Cage, Nickodemus, Michael Hurley, Slavic Soul Party, Maxwell, Tanya Morgan.

Choice Cuts: Wonderlick, Jamie Foxx, DJ Quik & Kurupt, They Might Be Giants, Balkan Beat Box, Robert Earl Keen.

More Duds: Chris Cornell, Ledisi, LeToya, Ziggy Marley, Bobby V.

Update Notes

Update today adds the last four months of Consumer Guides to the database. Note also that the external world has been treating us rudely: Barnes and Noble Review did a redesign that broke all of their existing links; MSN's recent Consumer Guide redesign more or less did the same thing; NPR changed their search page. Those at least are the ones I know about.

Rock & Roll &: Constructed Social Scenes

New Rock&Roll& column at Barnes & Noble Review: Thurston Moore/Byron Coley: No Wave; John Cook: Our Noise; Stuart Berman: This Book Is Broken.

Most Recent -- More Recent -- More Ancient

More Information