Robert Christgau: Dean of American Rock Critics

Consumer Guide:
  User's Guide
  Grades 1990-
  Grades 1969-89
  And It Don't Stop
Books:
  Book Reports
  Is It Still Good to Ya?
  Going Into the City
  Consumer Guide: 90s
  Grown Up All Wrong
  Consumer Guide: 80s
  Consumer Guide: 70s
  Any Old Way You Choose It
  Don't Stop 'til You Get Enough
Xgau Sez
Writings:
  And It Don't Stop
  CG Columns
  Rock&Roll& [new]
  Rock&Roll& [old]
  Music Essays
  Music Reviews
  Book Reviews
  NAJP Blog
  Playboy
  Blender
  Rolling Stone
  Billboard
  Video Reviews
  Pazz & Jop
  Recyclables
  Newsprint
  Lists
  Miscellany
Bibliography
NPR
Web Site:
  Home
  Site Map
  Contact
  What's New?
    RSS
Social Media:
  Substack
  Bluesky
  [Twitter]
Carola Dibbell:
  Carola's Website
  Archive
CG Search:
Google Search:

And It Don't Stop on Substack

Robert Christgau's newsletter And It Don't Stop appears three (or four) times a month on Substack. Subscribe here.

Robert Christgau's Big-Hearted Theory of Pop

Book Reports features reviews of not only the pop-music tomes you'd predict but also literary fiction, Marxist-adjacent cultural commentary, feminist debates over pornography, and even books about the past decade's financial crisis. It follows a collection that Christgau published last year, Is It Still Good to Ya? Fifty Years of Rock Criticism, 1967-2017, which includes Christgau's takes on, among many other things, classic rock, Kanye West, the music of Desert Storm, Lollapalooza, Ladysmith Black Mambazo, and so-called guilty pleasures--a category that Christgau rejects, since, for rock critics, as he puts it, "pleasure is where meaning begins." Together, these collections make the sneaky case that Christgau is not just the Dean of American Rock Critics, his self-awarded and perhaps slightly off-putting nickname, but one of America's sharper public intellectuals of the past half century, and certainly one of its most influential--not to mention one of the better stylists in that cohort. Fun is a big part of why.

--David Cantwell, The New Yorker

News

Expert Witness: Robert Christgau Takes on Mitski's Disquieting Angst

New in Expert Witness:

  • Mitski: Be the Cowboy (Dead Oceans) A-
  • Soccer Mommy: Clean (Fat Possum) A-
  • Adrianne Lenker: Abysskiss (Saddle Creek) *
  • Nice as Fuck: Nice as Fuck (Loves Way) *

New questions and answers were posted Tuesday, January 1: Xgau Sez.

Lupe Fiasco, Meek Mill, Lil Wayne, and Vince Staples

New in Expert Witness:

  • Lupe Fiasco: Drogas Wave (1st & 15th) A-
  • Meek Mill: Championships (Maybach Music Group) B+
  • Lil Wayne: Tha Carter V (Young Money) ***
  • Lupe Fiasco: Drogas Light (1st & 15th) **
  • Vince Staples: FM! (Def Jam) *

New questions and answers were posted Tuesday, December 18: Xgau Sez.

CupcakKe's Literotica and Leikeli47's Smokescreens

New in Expert Witness:

  • Cupcakke: Ephorize (Cupcakke) A-
  • Leikeli47: Acrylic (Hardcover/RCA) A-
  • Cupcakke: Queen Elizabitch (Cupcakke) B+
  • Leikeli47: Wash and Set (Hardcover/RCA) B+
  • Cupcakke: Eden (Cupcakke) ***

New questions and answers west will be posted on Tuesday, December 18: Xgau Sez.

The Goon Sax's Humble Reflections

New in Expert Witness:

  • The Goon Sax: We're Not Talking (Wichita Recordings) A-
  • Mad Crush: Mad Crush (Upon This Rock) B+
  • Flasher: Constant Image (Domino) ***
  • Weakened Friends: Common Blah (Don Giovanni) **

New questions and answers west posted on Tuesday, December 4: Xgau Sez.

Events, interviews, and reviews of Robert Christgau's recent book, Is It Still Good to Ya? Fifty Years of Rock Criticism 1967-2017:

Note: We are currently experiencing a problem with accented characters stored in the Consumer Guide database being presented as garbage.

New in Expert Witness:

  • Sons of Kemet: Your Queen Is a Reptile (Impulse!) A-
  • Doctor Nativo: Guatemaya (Stonetree) A-
  • Celestial Blues (Ace) ***
  • Sons of Kemet: Burn (Naim) **

New questions and answers on Tuesday, December 4: Xgau Sez.

L7's Feedback-Drenched, Feminist Aggro

New in Expert Witness:

  • L7: Fast andFrightening (Easy Action) A-
  • Joan Jett: Bad Reputation (Blackheart) A-
  • The Beths: Future Me Hates Me (Carpark) ***
  • Lala Lala: The Lamb (Hardly Art) *

New questions and answers last Tuesday: Xgau Sez.

Also note that the website now has a RSS 2.0 feed. It is (for now anyway) updated manually as new articles and/or significant revisions are made to the website.

Expert Witness: Some Inventive, Alternative Hip-Hop

New in Expert Witness:

  • Homeboy Sandman & Edan: Humble Pi (Stones Throw) A-
  • Open Mike Eagle: What Happens When I Try to Relax (Auto Reverse) A-
  • Atmosphere: Mi Vida Local (Rhymesayers) **
  • 2Mex: Lospital (Water the Plants) *
  • Red Pill: Instinctive Drowning (Mello Music) *

New questions and answers will be published on Tuesday, November 20: Xgau Sez.

Christgau's new book, Is It Still Good to Ya? Fifty Years of Rock Criticism 1967-2017, was published October 26 by Duke University Press.

Website was updated on Thursday, including all Expert Witness reviews from January to last week.

Expert Witness: Pistol Annies' Sharp 'Interstate Gospel'

New in Expert Witness:

  • Pistol Annies: Interstate Gospel (RCA) A
  • Becky Warren: Undesirable (self-released) A-
  • Mandy Barnett: Strange Conversation (Dame Productions/Thirty Tigers) A-
  • Robbie Fulks/Linda Gail Lewis: Wild! Wild! Wild! (Bloodshot) ***

New questions and answers were published on November 6: Xgau Sez.

Christgau's new book, Is It Still Good to Ya? Fifty Years of Rock Criticism 1967-2017, was published October 26 by Duke University Press. Some recent reviews and discussion:

Christgau also wrote a new essay about the new book:

Expert Witness: Rich Krueger's Ambition and Paul Simon's Farewell

New in Expert Witness:

  • Rich Krueger: NOWThen (Rockink) A-
  • Paul Simon: In the Blue Light (Legacy) A-
  • The Chandler Travis Three-O: Backward Crooked From the Sunset (Iddy Biddy) *
  • Rich Krueger: Overpass (CDBaby) *

New questions and answers will be posted on Tuesday, November 6, before the polls open: Xgau Sez.

Christgau's new book, Is It Still Good to Ya? Fifty Years of Rock Criticism 1967-2017, was released last week (October 26) by Duke University Press.

Expert Witness: A Tribute to Blue Lu Barker (and Blue Lu Herself)

New in Expert Witness:

  • Maria Muldaur: Dont You Feel My Leg: The Naughty Bawdy Blues of Blue Lu Barker (Last) A
  • Blue Lu Barker: Remastered Collection (J. Joes J. Edizioni Musicali) A-
  • George Jones & the Jones Boys: Live in Texas 1965 (Ace) ***
  • Duke Robillard and His Dames of Rhythm (M.C.) **
  • Willie Nelson: My Way (Legacy) *

New questions and answers were posted on Tuesday, October 23: Xgau Sez.

Christgau's new book, Is It Still Good to Ya? Fifty Years of Rock Criticism 1967-2017, was released today (October 26) by Duke University Press.

Expert Witness: Riton and Kah-Lo's Unrap

New in Expert Witness:

  • Riton & Kah-Lo: Foreign Ororo (Last Gang) A-
  • I'm Not Here to Hunt Rabits (Piranha) A-
  • Next Stop Soweto Vol. 4 (Strut) ***
  • Seun Kuti & Egypt 80: Black Times (Strut) *
Expert Witness: Ed Hamell's Brutal, Bastard-Bashing Fantasies

New in Expert Witness:

  • Hamell on Trial: The Night Guy at the Apocalypse: Profiles of a Rushing Midnight (Saustext) A
  • Lyrics Born: Quite a Life (Mobile Home) A-
  • Mudhoney: Digital Garbage (Sub Pop) ***
  • Will Hoge: My American Dream (Thirty Tigers/EDLO) **

New questions and answers were posted on Tuesday, October 9: Xgau Sez.

Expert Witness: On Noname's Poetic Breakthrough

New in Expert Witness:

  • Noname: Room 25 (self-relesed) A
  • The Internet: Hive mind (Columbia) A-
  • Blood Orange: Negro Swan (Domino) ***
  • Medhane: Ba Suba, Ak Jamm (Grand Closing) *
Expert Witness: On Eminem

New in Expert Witness:

  • Eminem: The Marshall Mathers LP 2 (Aftermath/Shady/Interscope) A
  • Eminem: Kamikaze (Aftermath/Shady/Interscope/Goliath) B+
  • Jean Grae & Quelle Chris: Everything's Fine (Mello Music) ***
  • E-40: The Gift of Gab (HTS) **
  • Rae Sremmurd: SR3MM (Eardruma/Interscope) *

New questions and answers were posted on Tuesday, September 18: Xgau Sez.

Expert Witness: Some Raggedy-Ass Rock and Some Tropical Fuck Storm

New in Expert Witness:

  • The Mekons 77: It Is Twice Blessed (Slow Things) A-
  • Tropical Fuck Storm: A Laughing Death in Meatspace (Tropical Fuck Storm/Mistletone) A-
  • Ceramic Dog: YRU Still Here? (Northern Spy) ***
  • Ike Reilly: Crooked Love (Rock Ridge) **
  • Marc Ribot: Songs of Resistance 1942-2018 (Anti-) *

Also new:

Also old, but new here:

Expert Witness: John Kruth's Broad Compass

New in Expert Witness:

  • John Kruth & La Società del Musici: Forever Ago (Ars Spoleteum) A-
  • Clay Harper: Bleak Beauty (self-released) B+
  • Sam Baker: Land of Doubtr (self-released) **
  • Chris Butler & Ralph Carney: Songs for Unsung Holidays (Smog Veil) **

New questions and answers were posted on Tuesday, September 4: Xgau Sez.

Expert Witness: Hinds' Good-Hearted Chops

New in Expert Witness:

  • Hinds: I Don't Run (Mom + Pop) A-
  • Bali Baby: Baylor Swift (Twin) A-
  • Kali Uchis: Isolation (Virgin EMI) ***
  • Primo!: Amici (Polyester) *
Xgau Sez

New questions and answers on Tuesday, August 21: Xgau Sez.

Expert Witness: Methodist Hospital's Goofy Apocalypse

New in Expert Witness:

  • Methodist Hospital: Giants (self-released) A-
  • Rolling Blackouts C.F.: Hope Downs (Sub Pop) B+
  • Stephen Malkmus and the Jicks: Sparkle Hard (Matador) ***
  • Low Cut Connie: "Dirty Pictures" (Part 2) (Contender) **
  • Young Fathers: Cocoa Sugar (Ninja Tune) **
  • Okkervil River: In the Rainbow Rain (ATO) *
  • Eyelids: or (Jealous Butcher/Schizophrenic) *

Also:

Expert Witness: Amanda Shires's Powers of Observation

New in Expert Witness:

  • Amanda Shires: To the Sunset (Silver Knife) A-
  • Lori McKenna: The Tree (CN/Thirty Tigers) B+
  • Sarah Shook & the Disarmers: Years (Bloodshot) **
  • Ashley Monroe: Sparrow (Warner Bros.) *

The second batch of answers to Xgau Sez was posted on Tuesday, at the top of the usual page.

Most Recent -- More Recent -- More Ancient

More Information